Current:Home > MyCarnival ruled negligent over cruise where 662 passengers got COVID-19 early in pandemic -TrueNorth Capital Hub
Carnival ruled negligent over cruise where 662 passengers got COVID-19 early in pandemic
View
Date:2025-04-17 03:04:13
CANBERRA, Australia (AP) — A cruise operator that failed to cancel a voyage from Sydney that led to a major COVID-19 outbreak was ruled negligent in its duty of care to passengers in an Australian class-action case Wednesday.
The Ruby Princess ocean liner left Sydney on March 8, 2020, with 2,671 passengers aboard for a 13-day cruise to New Zealand but returned in 11 days as Australia’s borders were closing. COVID-19 spread to 663 passengers and claimed 28 lives.
Passenger Susan Karpik was the lead plaintiff in the case against British-American cruise operator Carnival and its subsidiary Princess Cruises, the ship’s owner.
Federal Court Justice Angus Stewart ruled that Carnival had been negligent as defined by Australian consumer law by allowing the cruise to depart in the early months of the pandemic. He said Carnival had a duty to take reasonable care of her health and safety in regard to COVID-19.
“I have found that before the embarkation of passengers on the Ruby Princess for the cruise in question, the respondents knew or ought to have known about the heightened risk of coronavirus infection on the vessel and its potentially lethal consequences and that their procedures for screening passengers and crew members for the virus were unlikely to screen out all infectious individuals,” Stewart said.
Carnival had already experienced outbreaks on its cruises in the previous month aboard the Grand Princess off California and the Diamond Princess off Japan, the judge said.
Carnival had failed to explain why it offered free cancellation for all cruises worldwide leaving from March 9 — the day after the Ruby Princess departed — and suspended all cruises on March 13, he said.
“To the respondents’ knowledge, to proceed with the cruise carried significant risk of a coronavirus outbreak with possible disastrous consequences, yet they proceeded regardless,” Stewart said.
Susan Karpik had sued Carnival for more than 360,000 Australian dollars ($230,000).
However, she was only awarded her out-of-pocket medical expenses of AU$4,423.48 ($2,823.28) for reasons including that the judge did not accept she suffered from long COVID and that Carnival had refunded all the passengers’ fares.
But she said she was happy with the outcome.
“I was very pleased with that finding. And I hope the other passengers are pleased with that finding too,” she told reporters outside court.
“I hope the finding brings some comfort to them because they’ve all been through the mill and back,” she added.
Her lawyer Vicky Antzoulatos said other passengers who suffered worse consequences from their sickness could expect larger payouts.
While Susan Karpik’s symptoms were relatively mild, her husband Henry Karpik spent two months in hospital and almost died from his infection.
“Susan’s husband was very catastrophically injured, so we expect that he will have a substantial claim, and that will be the same for a number of the passengers on the ship,” Antzoulatos said.
Each passenger will have to prove their claims unless Carnival agrees to settle, she said.
“It’s been a long time coming and a very comprehensive victory for the passengers on the Ruby Princess,” Antzoulatos said.
Carnival Australia said in a statement it was considering the judgment in detail.
“The pandemic was a difficult time in Australia’s history, and we understand how heartbreaking it was for those affected,” Carnival said.
veryGood! (26)
Related
- Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
- Protesting farmers tighten squeeze on France’s government with ‘siege’ of Olympic host city Paris
- Wisconsin woman involved in Slender Man attack as child seeks release from psychiatric institute
- Former NHL player accused of sexual assault turns himself in to Ontario police
- Skins Game to make return to Thanksgiving week with a modern look
- North Macedonia parliament approves caretaker cabinet with first-ever ethnic Albanian premier
- A famed NYC museum is closing 2 Native American halls, and others have taken similar steps
- Former NHL player Alex Formenton has been charged by police in Canada, his lawyer says
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- 'Gray divorce' rates have doubled. But it's a costly move, especially for women
Ranking
- Nearly 400 USAID contract employees laid off in wake of Trump's 'stop work' order
- Teen awaiting trial in 2020 homicide who fled outside hospital is captured in Philadelphia
- Malaysia charges former minister for not declaring assets, as graft probe targets allies of ex-PM
- San Francisco 49ers have gold rush in second half of NFC championship
- Paris Hilton, Nicole Richie return for an 'Encore,' reminisce about 'The Simple Life'
- 52 killed in clashes in the disputed oil-rich African region of Abyei, an official says
- Suddenly unemployed in your 50s? What to do about insurance, savings and retirement.
- NFL schedule today: Everything to know about playoff games on Jan. 28
Recommendation
A White House order claims to end 'censorship.' What does that mean?
2 accused of racing held for trial in crash with school van that killed a teen and injured others
Felipe Nasr, Porsche teammates give Roger Penske his first overall Rolex 24 win since 1969
Small biz owners scale back their office space or go remote altogether. Some move to the suburbs
Which apps offer encrypted messaging? How to switch and what to know after feds’ warning
Former New Jersey public official gets probation after plea to misusing township workers
Who is No Doubt? Gwen Stefani had to explain band to son ahead of Coachella reunion
In Oregon, a New Program Is Training Burn Bosses to Help Put More “Good Fire” on the Ground