Current:Home > MyEthermac|Unhinged yet uplifting, 'Poor Things' is an un-family-friendly 'Barbie' -TrueNorth Capital Hub
Ethermac|Unhinged yet uplifting, 'Poor Things' is an un-family-friendly 'Barbie'
Ethermac Exchange View
Date:2025-04-06 10:25:55
Poor Things is Ethermaca little Alice in Wonderland, a little Wizard of Oz, a little Marquis de Sade and a whole lot of Frankenstein. It also has a lot in common with some of Yorgos Lanthimos' earlier films, like The Favourite and Dogtooth: transgressive sex, sadistic power games and grisly violence.
But if the movie is brutal, it's also extravagantly beautiful, extremely funny and, by the end, strangely touching, even uplifting. This may be Lanthimos' most unhinged movie, but it also has a joyous exuberance that I haven't felt in much of his earlier work.
The story, loosely adapted from a 1992 novel by the Scottish writer Alasdair Gray, follows a most unusual character named Bella Baxter, played by a mesmerizing Emma Stone. When we first meet Bella in 19th-century London, she looks like an adult woman but has the awkward gait, unformed speech and anarchic spirit of a very young child.
As we learn early on, she's the product of a back-from-the-dead mad science experiment, in which she was implanted with the brain of the child she was carrying at the time of her death. Bella, in other words, is both her mother and her daughter — and, in a weird way, neither.
Under the watchful eye of her creator — that's Willem Dafoe as the sweetly deranged scientist Dr. Godwin Baxter — Bella develops rapidly. Before long, she's walking and talking more or less like a grown-up, though her inventively tortured speech patterns remain one of the best running gags in Tony McNamara's script.
Inevitably, Bella discovers sex, first exploring her own adult body with childlike curiosity, and then having a passionate fling with a rogue named Duncan Wedderburn — a hilariously over-the-top Mark Ruffalo. When they have sex for the first time, the movie, which until now has mostly been filmed in black-and-white, explodes into wild, rapturous color.
Like an especially bawdy riff on Voltaire's Candide, Poor Things becomes the story of Bella's sexual odyssey. Ever since the movie's Venice Film Festival premiere, much of the reaction has focused on its many frenzied sex scenes, in which the bodies of Stone and Ruffalo, among others, are on abundant display. But the movie is after something more than mere titillation; much of the time, it emphasizes the absurdity rather than the ecstasy of sex.
Before long, Bella grows bored — and disillusioned. She learns that men are mostly horrible, and that the world is full of suffering and poverty. Soon, she begins making new friends, reading Emerson and nourishing her mind. At one point, while they're on a European boat cruise, Duncan becomes jealous, accusing Bella of spending too much time with two other travelers, who are having an engrossing intellectual debate. Bella responds, as she often does, by referring to herself in the third person: "These two are fighting and ideas are banging around in Bella's head and heart like lights in a storm."
If Bella's baroque dialogue makes Poor Things a lot of fun to listen to, the film is also gorgeous to look at. Lanthimos has never been afraid of anachronism, and here he embraces it head-on. His production designers, Shona Heath and James Price, have dreamed up a futuristic, candy-colored vision of the 19th century, where people movers soar over city streets and chimneys belch green smoke into a dark purple sky.
This almost Steampunk fantasy version of Victoriana, often shot with fish-eye lenses by the gifted cinematographer Robbie Ryan, suggests just how radically strange the world must look to Bella's eyes. And Jerskin Fendrix's dissonant, unruly score feels like something piped in directly from Bella's subconscious.
Some admirers of Poor Things have argued that it's a feminist work, in which Bella's erotic awakening becomes the key to her liberation. The movie's detractors have dismissed it as just a superficially empowering girlboss narrative. I'm hardly the only one to have noticed that it's basically the un-family-friendly version of Barbie, in which a woman's childlike naiveté becomes a surprisingly effective weapon against the patriarchy. I guess that makes Ruffalo's greasy-haired Duncan a Ken, though you might say the same for the men played by Ramy Youssef, Jerrod Carmichael and Christopher Abbott, all of whom try, in their own ways, to manipulate Bella's destiny.
But Bella won't be controlled, and she's much too brilliant a character to be reduced to a symbol or archetype. Stone gives a great, audacious performance; her Bella can be ignorant, selfish, impulsive and cruel, but also fiercely intelligent, witty, thoughtful and kind. Lanthimos has seldom expressed much affection for his characters, but he clearly loves this one to pieces. He's made a movie that, even at its most outlandish, has its heart in the right place, even if its brains are not.
veryGood! (61923)
Related
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- Teen Mom’s Tyler Baltierra Reacts to “Disappointing” Decision From Carly's Adoptive Parents
- Civil War General William T. Sherman’s sword and other relics to be auctioned off in Ohio
- What to watch this weekend, from the latest 'Planet of the Apes' to the new 'Doctor Who'
- Macy's says employee who allegedly hid $150 million in expenses had no major 'impact'
- In Louisiana’s ‘Cancer Alley,’ Excitement Over New Emissions Rules Is Tempered By a Legal Challenge to Federal Environmental Justice Efforts
- Iowa sex trafficking victim who killed alleged abuser sought by authorities
- When could you see the northern lights? Aurora forecast for over a dozen states this weekend
- Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
- Pacers coach Rick Carlisle has a point about NBA officiating but not small-market bias
Ranking
- Paula Abdul settles lawsuit with former 'So You Think You Can Dance' co
- Tesla’s Autopilot caused a fiery crash into a tree, killing a Colorado man, lawsuit says
- Sewage spill closes waters along 2 miles of Los Angeles beaches
- Rapper NBA YoungBoy is held on $100K bail in Utah prescription fraud case
- Newly elected West Virginia lawmaker arrested and accused of making terroristic threats
- Most of 15 million bees contained after bee-laden truck crashes
- Cicadas will soon become a massive, dead and stinky mess. There's a silver lining.
- Summer House: Martha's Vineyard: Nick, Noelle and Shanice Clash During Tense House Meeting
Recommendation
Meta releases AI model to enhance Metaverse experience
He's been in an LA hospital for weeks and they have no idea who he is. Can you help?
Meghan Markle Details Moving Moment She Had With Her and Prince Harry’s Daughter Lilibet
Cushion or drain? Minimum-wage hike for food delivery drivers may get cut after debate in Seattle
Trump issues order to ban transgender troops from serving openly in the military
She was the chauffeur, the encourager and worked for the NSA. But mostly, she was my mom
After infertility, other struggles, these moms are grateful to hear 'Happy Mother's Day'
Man pleads guilty in theft of bronze Jackie Robinson statue from Kansas park