Current:Home > ContactRecord numbers in the US are homeless. Can cities fine them for sleeping in parks and on sidewalks? -TrueNorth Capital Hub
Record numbers in the US are homeless. Can cities fine them for sleeping in parks and on sidewalks?
View
Date:2025-04-15 13:18:16
WASHINGTON (AP) — The most significant case in decades on homelessness has reached the Supreme Court as record numbers of people in America are without a permanent place to live.
The justices on Monday will consider a challenge to rulings from a California-based appeals court that found punishing people for sleeping outside when shelter space is lacking amounts to unconstitutional cruel and unusual punishment.
A political cross section of officials in the West and California, home to nearly one-third of the nation’s homeless population, argue those decisions have restricted them from “common sense” measures intended to keep homeless encampments from taking over public parks and sidewalks.
Advocacy groups say the decisions provide essential legal protections, especially with an increasing number of people forced to sleep outdoors as the cost of housing soars.
The case before the Supreme Court comes from Grants Pass, a small city nestled in the mountains of southern Oregon, where rents are rising and there is just one overnight shelter for adults. As a growing number of tents clustered its parks, the city banned camping and set $295 fines for people sleeping there.
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals largely blocked the camping ban under its finding that it is unconstitutional to punish people for sleeping outside when there is not adequate shelter space. Grants Pass appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing the ruling left it few good options.
“It really has made it impossible for cities to address growing encampments, and they’re unsafe, unhealthy and problematic for everyone, especially those who are experiencing homelessness,” said lawyer Theane Evangelis, who is representing Grants Pass.
The city is also challenging a 2018 decision, known as Martin v. Boise, that first barred camping bans when shelter space is lacking. It was issued by the San Francisco-based 9th Circuit and applies to the nine Western states in its jurisdiction. The Supreme Court declined to take up a different challenge to the ruling in 2019, before the solidification of its current conservative majority.
If the decision is overturned, advocates say it would make it easier for cities deal with homelessness by arresting and fining people rather than helping them get shelter and housing.
“In Grants Pass and across America, homelessness has grown because more and more hardworking people struggle to pay rent, not because we lack ways to punish people sleeping outside,” said Jesse Rabinowitz, campaign and communications director for the National Homeless Law Center. Local laws prohibiting sleeping in public spaces have increased at least 50% since 2006, he said.
The case comes after homelessness in the United States grew by 12%, to its highest reported level as soaring rents and a decline in coronavirus pandemic assistance combined to put housing out of reach for more people, according to federal data. Four in 10 people experiencing homelessness sleep outside, a federal report found.
More than 650,000 people are estimated to be homeless, the most since the country began using the yearly point-in-time survey in 2007. People of color, LGBTQ+ people and seniors are disproportionately affected, advocates said.
Two of four states with the country’s largest homeless populations, Washington and California, are in the West. Officials in cities such as Los Angeles and San Francisco say they do not want to punish people simply because they are forced to sleep outside, but that cities need the power to keep growing encampments in check.
“I never want to criminalize homelessness, but I want to be able to encourage people to accept services and shelter,” said Thien Ho, the district attorney in Sacramento, California, where homelessness has risen sharply in recent years.
San Francisco says it has been blocked from enforcing camping regulations because the city does not have enough shelter space for its full homeless population, something it estimates would cost $1.5 billion to provide.
“These encampments frequently block sidewalks, prevent employees from cleaning public thoroughfares, and create health and safety risks for both the unhoused and the public at large,” lawyers for the city wrote. City workers have also encountered knives, drug dealing and belligerent people at encampments, they said.
Several cities and Democratic California Gov. Gavin Newsom urged the high court to keep some legal protections in place while reining in “overreach” by lower courts. The Martin v. Boise ruling allows cities to regulate and “sweep” encampments, but not enforce total bans in communities without enough beds in shelters.
The Justice Department also backed the idea that people shouldn’t be punished for sleeping outside when they have no where else to go, but said the Grants Pass ruling should be tossed out because 9th Circuit went awry by not defining what it means to be “involuntarily homeless.”
Evangelis, the lawyer for Grants Pass, argues that the Biden administration’s position would not solve the problem for the Oregon city. “It would be impossible for cities to really address the homelessness crisis,” she said.
Public encampments are not good places for people to live, said Ed Johnson, who represents people living outside in Grants Pass as director of litigation at the Oregon Law Center. But enforcement of camping bans often makes homelessness worse by requiring people to spend money on fines rather than housing or creating an arrest record that makes it harder to get an apartment. Public officials should focus instead on addressing shortages of affordable housing so people have places to live, he said.
“It’s frustrating when people who have all the power throw up their hands and say, ‘there’s nothing we can do,’” he sad. “People have to go somewhere.”
The Supreme Court is expected to rule by the end of June.
veryGood! (89615)
Related
- IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
- Christina Hall Officially Replaces Ex Josh Hall With Ex-Husband Ant Anstead on The Flip Off
- Scam losses worldwide this year are $1 trillion. How to protect yourself.
- Taylor Swift could win her fifth album of the year Grammy: All her 2025 nominations
- Opinion: Gianni Infantino, FIFA sell souls and 2034 World Cup for Saudi Arabia's billions
- The story of how Trump went from diminished ex-president to a victor once again
- College Football Playoff elimination games: Which teams desperately need Week 11 win?
- Video captures mountain lion in Texas backyard; wildlife department confirms sighting
- The Louvre will be renovated and the 'Mona Lisa' will have her own room
- Mother fatally shot when moving daughter out of Iowa home; daughter's ex-boyfriend arrested
Ranking
- Have Dry, Sensitive Skin? You Need To Add These Gentle Skincare Products to Your Routine
- Brother of Buffalo’s acting mayor dies in fall from tree stand while hunting
- Gold medalist Noah Lyles beats popular streamer IShowSpeed in 50m race
- Judge strikes down Biden administration program shielding immigrant spouses from deportation
- NHL in ASL returns, delivering American Sign Language analysis for Deaf community at Winter Classic
- Mother fatally shot when moving daughter out of Iowa home; daughter's ex-boyfriend arrested
- 'Everything on sale': American Freight closing all stores amid parent company's bankruptcy
- Elwood Edwards, Voice of AOL’s “You’ve Got Mail” Message, Dead at 74
Recommendation
North Carolina trustees approve Bill Belichick’s deal ahead of introductory news conference
Watch these classic animal welfare stories in National Animal Shelter Appreciation Week
Man is charged in highway shootings around North Carolina’s capital city
Brianna Chickenfry LaPaglia Speaks Out After Detailing Zach Bryan’s Alleged Emotional Abuse
Military service academies see drop in reported sexual assaults after alarming surge
Racist text messages referencing slavery raise alarms in multiple states and prompt investigations
Partial list of nominees for the 2025 Grammy Awards
NY YouTuber 1Stockf30 dies in fatal car crash 'at a high rate of speed': Police